Firm picks best, worst college savings plans

sfgate_get_fprefs();

Morningstar released its yearly listing of the five best and five worst 529 college nest egg programs on Wednesday. Past favourites Beehive State Educational Savings and Cornhusker State College Savings dropped out of the top five, not because they got worse, but because other programs got better.

As usual, California's ScholarShare 529 program made neither list.

"It's in the middle. It's neither here nor there," states Morningstar analyst Marta Norton. "It have some of the failings we are bothered by in 529 land, along with some of the things you desire to see."

Named after a subdivision of the Internal Gross Code, 529 programs are state-sponsored programs that supply federal taxation benefits for college savings. You can put them up for your kids, grandkids, other loved 1s or yourself. There are no income limits, and most programs allow you lend big six-figure sums.

You acquire no federal taxation tax deduction for money you set into the plan, but the money turns tax-free and stays tax-free when you take it out, as long as it's used for qualified higher instruction disbursals at almost any public or private college in the country. States also exempt net income and qualified backdowns from state income taxes.

No substance where you live, you can put in any state's plan. Some states offering a state taxation tax deduction for parts or other fringe benefits when their ain occupants put in the home-state plan. Golden State offers no such as incentives, so there's no taxation ground to pick ScholarShare over any other state's plan.

Most states engage investing houses to run their programs. Many states offering two plans: one sold by agents (who usually complaint a gross gross sales commission) and one that is sold directly to investors without a jobber or sales fee.

Most offering a assortment of investing options, such as as money market, chemical bond and stock finances as well as age-based finances that gradually go more than conservative as a kid acquires older.

Morningstar's top-rated plans this twelvemonth are direct-sold plans from Illinois, Old Line State and Old Dominion and broker-sold plans from Old Dominion and Colorado. Costs are a top concern

Morningstar wishes programs that supply a broad assortment of plus social classes for diversification, low costs, solid implicit in finances and the flexibleness to easily do changes.

Costs are a peculiar concern, because they come up directly out of returns.

In many plans, "there are layer upon layer of fees," Norton says. In improver to the implicit in monetary fund fees, many complaint programme or account-maintenance fees, plus - in the lawsuit of broker-sold funds - gross sales commissions.

The Prairie State Bright Start program joined the top five listing this twelvemonth after it switched directors and cut fees.

Also new to the best listing is the Old Dominion Education Savings Trust, a direct-sold monetary fund that offerings a broad array of options (including existent estate, international and inflation-protected funds) at a very low cost (asset-based fees scope from 0.31 to 0.57 percentage per year).

These finances replaced Utah's and Nebraska's direct-sold programs on the list. "Both of those are still very good plans," Norton says. "They haven't raised their price. In fact, Beehive State lowered the yearly care fee for nonresidents."

It's just that "in both cases, there was a cheaper rival that undercut them," she said.

Norton named the Old Dominion direct-sold program as her top pick for hands-on investors who like to pull off their college savings. For hands-off investors, she wishes the Prairie State program because its index-fund option is "very cheap" and "does everything for you."

Morningstar's worst listing includes direct-sold plans from Mississippi River River and New House Of York and broker-sold plans from Ohio, Mississippi and Nebraska. How Golden State fares

The Cornhusker State purpose program is the lone hangover from last year's bottom-five listing and stands in blunt direct contrast to Nebraska's highly rated direct-sold plan. Although the purpose program have made some changes, its asset-based fees are still high, ranging up to 1.61 percent.

As for California's ScholarShare plan, Norton says, "it could be improved."

In November 2006, the state replaced TIAA-CREF, which had been managing ScholarShare since its inception, with Fidelity.

Assets in the direct-sold program have got grown to $2.9 billion from $2.2 billion since Fidelity took over.

Fidelity added a broker-sold version, called ScholarShare Adviser College Savings Plan, which have attracted $81 million in assets.

Fidelity increased the figure of investing options, but Wenli Tan, who follows the program for Morningstar, states it misses entree to some of Fidelity's best finances and "doesn't have got much exposure" to little and midsize companies and value-oriented stocks.

Morningstar also observes that Fidelity's "short and intermediate chemical bond finances have got stumbled in recent calendar months owed to their exposure to commercial mortgage-backed and subprime-backed bonds.

"Though we believe these finances will happen their terms again, their recent battles nevertheless raise a reddish flag, as they are supposed to be the plan's most conservative offerings."

I checked the public presentation of ScholarShare's more than conservative 529 investing options, which be given to have got a bigger per centum of these chemical bond funds, and establish them to be in line with or slightly ahead of their peers. 'Challenging market'

In an e-mail, Fidelity spokeswoman Sophie Launay said, "Like other fixed-income funds, our nonexempt chemical bond finances have got faced a ambitious marketplace environment. I can state you, though, we have got experienced fixed-income portfolio directors at the helm of these funds. While our investing tactics go on to germinate with current conditions, we stay deeply committed to the procedures that have got added value for stockholders and clients over the years."

Norton states that ScholarShare offers "reasonable" investing options and that its fees are "OK."

In the broker-sold plan, fees scope from 0.55 percentage per twelvemonth for index finances to between 0.78 and 1.09 percentage for actively managed funds.

For the full study on 529 plans, travel to . To research person plans, chink on 529 Plan Finder.

For a different reappraisal of 529 programs from Finaid.com, travel to .
Rating college nest egg programs

These are Morningstar's five best and five worst 529 programs for 2008. Unless celebrated as agent sold, programs are sold directly to investors without a gross sales commission. Best

Name

Manager

Illinois Bright Start College Savings Program

Oppenheimer Funds

Maryland College Inv. Plan

T. Rowe Price

Virginia CollegeAmerica*

Virginia (American Funds)

Virginia Education Savings Trust

Virginia

Colorado Scholars Choice College Savings Program*

Legg Mason

*Broker sold
Worst

Name

Manager

Ohio Putnam CollegeAdvantage*

Putnam

Mississippi Low-Cost College Savings Program

TIAA-CREF

Mississippi Low-Cost College Savings Program*

TIAA-CREF

New House Of York 529 College Savings Program

Upromise

Nebraska purpose College Savings Plan*

Union Depository Financial Institution (AIM)

*Broker sold

Source: Morningstar

Net Worth runs Tuesdays, Thursdays and Sundays. E-mail Kathleen Pender at .